Guest: Matt Edmundson
Learning Is Not the Same as Implementation
After recording 200+ episodes of the eCommerce Podcast, I've noticed something troubling. Everyone's taking notes. Nobody's taking action.
Sure, I get comments from our amazing listeners all the time. "Great insights!" "Made loads of notes!" "Can't wait to try this!" But then... silence. Well. Almost. I hear very few implementation stories.
And honestly, I am just as guilty. I am great at creating more notes that end up gathering digital dust in that folder labelled "Great Ideas."
I've interviewed hundreds of experts. Made countless notes. Downloaded every framework. And probably implemented about 5% of what I've learned. Sound familiar?
Knowing about it is not the same as doing it
Just last week, I was interviewing yet another brilliant expert about conversion optimisation. Mid-conversation, they mentioned something about post-purchase sequences, and I found myself thinking, "That's exactly what so-and-so guest told me three years ago. And it is what another guest mentioned last month. And what that course I bought covered..."
We're all drowning in good advice while our businesses stay exactly the same.
The eCommerce industry has become an echo chamber of surface-level tips and recycled wisdom. "5 Ways to Boost Conversions!" "The Secret to Facebook Ads!" "How This Founder Went from Zero to Hero!"
But nobody talks about the real problem: knowing what to do has never been easier. Actually doing it? That's where we all fall apart.
Going back to our roots
The eCommerce Podcast actually started with solo episodes.
Go back five or six years in the archives (though I'll warn you, I cringe listening to them now), and you'll find me sitting alone with a microphone, sharing what I thought people needed to hear. The knowledge was there, but the delivery? Let's just say I've learned a thing or two about storytelling since then.
So I pivoted to interviews. I thought the shows were more interesting (and definitely a lot easier to create). And it worked brilliantly – the show grew, we built an amazing audience, and I learned from the best in the business.
But something was missing.
Every interview taught me something new, but it also highlighted the same frustrating pattern. We'd discuss these game-changing strategies, and I'd see listeners get excited, but then... very little would change. Because learning about Instagram marketing from an expert is one thing. Figuring out how to actually implement it in your specific business when you're already working 60-hour weeks? That's something else entirely.
The £38 Million Lesson About Real Business
I wonder if part of the problem is that most of the content out there is created by folks who haven't actually been in the trenches. They share theory, not scars.
Well, I've got scars.
A few years ago, we had an online business doing £6 million annually. Within months, that halved. Then it dropped to about £1 million. All because of one catastrophic relationship with a key supplier.
They instituted a "more you buy, more you pay" policy, and we were completely blindsided. Overnight, our entire business model – built on volume discounting and efficiency – became obsolete.
I call it my £38 million lesson, because that's roughly how much in sales we lost.
That experience taught me that real business isn't about collecting tips and tricks; it's about building a solid foundation. It's about building systems that can survive when everything goes wrong. It's about taking action even when you don't have perfect information.
It's about implementation, not inspiration.
Building Bridges, Not Just Broadcasting
So here's what's changing.
First, I'm bringing back solo episodes. But not like those early cringeworthy attempts. These will be different:
- Shorter and sharper: 20-minute deep dives on specific challenges (because after 20 minutes of just me, even I get bored)
- Real implementation details: Not just what works, but exactly how to make it work in your business
- Stories from the trenches: What we're actually doing in our own businesses and with our clients
- No hidden agendas: When experts come on, they're amazing, but they're also promoting something. These solo episodes? Just pure, unfiltered insights
We're also launching something bigger that you may have heard me talk about on the show, if you're a regular listener, and that's eCommerce Cohorts. These are free membership groups where you can work alongside other entrepreneurs to actually implement what you're learning.
Because here's what I've discovered: you can listen to 1,000 podcasts alone, or you can work through 10 ideas with peers who get it. Guess which one actually moves your business forward?
One cohort member recently went from working two days a week on his business to three days – not because of some magical tactic, but because working with others gave him the confidence and clarity to take the leap. Sure, it's not the "Went from Zero to a Million in 30 days" story. But that's good. That story is for 0.0001% of our listeners. Getting the opportunity to reduce your part-time job to work more full-time on your business, well, that applies to 10,000% more.
The Business Model Nobody Talks About
Let me be completely transparent about why I'm doing this.
Yes, the podcast helps grow our business. We've built multiple seven-figure operations, and a significant portion of that success stems from relationships established through this content. When I give value freely, I meet amazing people. Some become clients. Some become partners. We've even acquired businesses through connections made here.
That's exactly why I can continue to offer what others charge thousands for. My coaching rate is $4,000 a day. The frameworks we share? Companies pay serious money for them. Yet here they are, free on a podcast.
Why? Because the more I help people grow, the more our ecosystem thrives. The more successful eCommerce businesses there are, the more potential partners we have. The more I learn from implementing alongside you, the better I can serve our equity partners and clients.
It's not charity. It's building a rising tide that lifts all boats.
What Happens Next
Over the coming weeks, you'll see this evolution roll out:
New solo episodes tackling the stuff that really matters. First up: we're discussing the summer sales slump and, of course, Black Friday. Then we'll dig into the mindset shifts that separate six-figure survivors from seven-figure thrivers.
The eCommerce Cohort launches properly. These aren't courses – they're implementation groups. Think of them as your board of advisors, except everyone's in the trenches with you.
A newsletter that actually delivers. Not just "here's this week's episode," but real additional value. The stuff I can't fit in 20 minutes.
So here's my ask of you:
Join the cohort. Even if you're sceptical. Especially if you're drowning in "great ideas" you'll never implement alone. It's also free. You've really got nothing to lose.
Send me your actual problems. Not "how do I scale?" but "I'm spending £1,000 a month on Facebook ads and my ROAS is 1.8 – what would you do?" Real questions get real answers.
Stop taking notes. Start taking action. Pick one thing from each episode and actually do it. Then tell me what happened.
The Uncomfortable Truth About Success
After 20+ years in eCommerce, after building and selling multiple businesses, after that £38 million lesson, here's what I know for sure:
The difference between the businesses that thrive and those that merely survive isn't knowledge. It's not even talent. It's the ability to take imperfect action consistently.
Everyone's waiting for the perfect strategy, the revolutionary tactic, the course that changes everything. But the real secret? It's doing the basics brilliantly, learning from what actually happens (not what should happen), and having people around you who get it.
That's what these solo episodes are about. That's what the cohort is about. That's what this entire evolution is about.
Because learning is not the same as implementation.
And I reckon it's time we all stopped pretending otherwise.
---
P.S. Remember that folder of "Great Ideas" on your desktop? Open it right now. Pick one thing. Implement it this week. Then drop me a note about what happened. I read every single one, and the best implementation stories might just become future episode topics.
After all, your implementation story is worth more than another expert's theory.
Links for Matt
[00:00:00]
Matt Edmundson: If you are like me, then somewhere in your digital ecosystem is a folder called Great Ideas, and that folder has a layer of digital dust on it because it is rarely opened. Right after recording hundreds of episodes of the e-Commerce podcast, having interviewed some incredible experts in their field, having coached companies all around the world, and if I'm totally honest, taking a really long look at the mirror myself, there is the same repeating mistake we all seem to be making.
That is,
we rarely put into practice what we have learned.
So I want to talk about
that today and I want to dig into it and share some changes that are also happening, uh, here on e-Commerce Podcast to help us all become better at implementing. Of course, if you are [00:01:00] already perfect implementation, this show might not be for you, in which case.
Come and be my guest and share your insights because I would genuinely love to hear them. But if you are like me, then you probably struggle in this area, right? Just last week I sat there interviewing this brilliant expert about conversion optimization. Fantastic person really knew their stuff. But partway through the conversation, they start talking about post-purchase sequences and how critical they are for customer retention.
And I'm nodding along because I'm really fascinated, I'm making all the right noises. I'm writing notes in my notebook, I'm asking follow-up questions, but it struck me in my mind, you know, I'm, I sort of thought to myself. Well, this is exactly what, uh, a guest told me three years ago and what another guest mentioned last month and what that 2000 pound course I bought covered in module [00:02:00] four.
Right, and I don't think I'm the only 1:00 AM I, if you look at the stats for online courses, and let's face it, there are more courses than we could possibly need right now. Uh, between two and 8% of original starters, realistically both finish and puts the knowledge into practice. That's a low percentage, but that's me.
Right? And I've interviewed the experts, hundreds of them. I've made pages and pages and pages of notes. Uh, I've downloaded every single framework, every template, every checklist.
But the reality of it is I've probably implemented about 5% of what I've learned. 5%. That's it.
And if you're honest with yourself.
I bet your number isn't that much higher and you know, I could sit here and justify we're all busy people. Uh, we've all got stuff to do and I think we're all drowning in good advice, aren't we? [00:03:00] While our businesses stay exactly the same, the e-commerce industry has become this sort of echo chamber of surface level tips and recycled wisdom.
You know, the things, I mean, the sort of five ways to boost conversions. The secret to Facebook ads. I dunno how many secrets there are to Facebook ads, but there's millions of people telling me that they found the secret to it. There's a lot of secrets, right? Um, and my personal favorite is the how This founder went from zero to hero in, you know, some crazy amount of time, like 30 days or something like that.
But no one seems to be talking about the real problem, which I think is well simply this knowing what to do. That's never been easier. I mean, just think about what you have access to now, the internet and with ai, I mean, the stuff that you can find out within a matter of seconds
is mind boggling. So knowing what to do has never been easier [00:04:00] actually doing it well. That's where things come unstuck. You know,
I started the e-commerce podcast back in 2019 and I actually started with these sort of solo episodes where I had no guests, no interviews, just me and a microphone, a bit like this one. And yes, it is a little different if you're a regular to the show, um, you can still listen to those original ones, and I know a lot of you do.
I, I know a lot of. People who go back like five, six years in the archives determined to listen to all of the episodes. And I take my hat off to you. I really do. That's a lot of episodes to listen to. Um, I, I think the, the early ones are a little bit cringe if I listen to them now. Not because necessarily the content was wrong, but because, well, I dunno if you've ever heard a recording of yourself from years ago, it can be a slightly painful experience.
Right. I had all of this knowledge from running my own eCommerce businesses, from the coaching that I'd been doing, but I, [00:05:00] I think I've learned a lot over the recent years in terms of how to communicate those better, more effectively. I just, the way I did them was I just sit down, you know, with a rough idea and to start talking.
No structure, no stories, just. Really an information dump. And, uh, so I did what any self-respect in Britt would do when faced with potential embarrassment. Um, I got other people to share their expertise. That's exactly what I did. I pivoted to interviews and I learned how to ask questions and how, uh, and just dig to dig into things.
And you know what, for me it was brilliant. Um, the show grew. We built this amazing audience. I learned from the absolute best in the business. And if you've been a guest on the show, I really appreciate you guys coming on and sharing your knowledge and insight. It's much easier to ask questions than to answer them in so many ways, but, you know, something was missing for me.[00:06:00]
Um, so when we've been thinking about e-Commerce podcast and, and going over it in our minds. I just wondered whether we needed to change a little bit. You see, every interview taught me something new, but it also highlighted the same pattern. We talk about these game changing strategies and listeners would get excited.
You know, we would all make notes and I know this because you write in and you tell me, right? Um, but then what changes as a result of that? I get the occasional story of things that change, but not lots, because on average, 5% implementation seems to be about. Where everybody's at. So you take the example of learning about Instagram marketing from an expert.
Well, that's one thing, but figuring out how to actually implement what they have said, the lessons they've given in, into your sort of specific business. When you're already working 60 hours a week and you've got inventory issues, you've got, you know, supplier issues, they've just raised the prices. [00:07:00] It's hard, isn't it?
It's hard to implement. It's hard to figure out specifically for your business. And I wonder if part of the problem is that most of the content out there is created by people that have actually not been
in the trenches. They share theory, but they do not share scars. Well, if you are
an E-commerce, like I'm, if you are an eCommercer like I am, I love that word.
Um. Then you're gonna have scars. You've got them. I've got them. I even have
what I call my $38 million scar, which was
created about 10 years ago. Uh, we had this online business. It was doing about 6 million a year. It was a good business, solid growth. Everything was working. But within months, revenue had halved.
And after a few months beyond that, before the end of the financial year, we were down to about a million a year. We lost 5 million a year in sales. So what happened? Why did we do that? Well, there's lots of reasons, but one of them was we had a ca [00:08:00] catastrophic, that's not an easy word to say, a catastrophic relationship with a key supplier.
It totally went sideways. They instituted what I call a more you buy, the more you pay policy, which I appreciate is the complete opposite of how many businesses normally work. That's what happened. We were completely blindsided. There's no doubt about it, right? Overnight, our entire business model built on volume, discounting and efficiency became obsolete.
Everything we knew about scaling, about growth, about business economics, they didn't help me one bit. We had to relearn almost everything, and that's why I call it my $38 million mistake because. If I'm honest with you, I think that's how much we lost in sales over the years because of what happened with that supplier.
And one of the things that I learned the hard way through that whole
experience was that [00:09:00] real business isn't about collecting tips and tricks. It's not about
having the first back, uh, the, the perfect get my words right. It's not about having the perfect Facebook ad strategy or the ultimate email sequence.
It's about building systems that can survive when everything else goes wrong. It's about taking action even when you don't have perfect information. In other words,
it's about implementation, not inspiration. So here's what's
changing on the e-commerce podcast. Let me bring you up to speed with some of the things that are going on.
First, I am bringing back. Uh, solo episodes. Hopefully not the, you know, the cringe-worthy earlier episodes that we did. Uh, hopefully these are gonna be different. They're gonna be shorter and sharper. Uh, about 20 minutes, uh, in length. And we're gonna look at specific challenges during those 20 minutes because if I'm honest with you, after 20 minutes of just me.[00:10:00]
Steve and I get bored with the sound of my own voice. And so I really, and I really like the sound of my own voice. Uh, anyway, 20 minutes is what we're aiming for. Uh, it doesn't mean that we're not gonna be bringing the expert interviews, we're still doing those, which is what the show was founded on. And also we're doing more founder episodes as well.
So we're gonna have three episode types. This, these, we call them internally the solo episodes, which is me talking about I need to come up with a better name really. If you have any ideas, do let me know, but this is where I'm gonna talk about e-commerce as I see it, share some stories and stuff. We're gonna have the expert, uh, interviews, which is what we've been doing, where we bring in experts in their field and we are also gonna have the founder episodes.
Uh, why am I doing this? Well, let me tell you, there is no hidden agenda, uh, total transparency, you know, when experts come on the show, um, they're amazing. Don't get me wrong. I think they're brilliant and I, I, I love what they're doing and I love talking to them, but. They are also promoting something more often than not, right.
Their [00:11:00] agency, their software, their course, um, that's the deal and that's fine with me. They come on the show, we talk about a specific area. If they deliver value, there's a chance you may sign up to their services or at least connect with 'em and find out more. Right? I get that. But these solo episodes, I didn't want any of that.
I just wanted sort of pure, unfiltered. Conversation really. Um, just from the stuff that I'm doing every day, uh, and learning about e-commerce. So we're gonna be talking about real implementation, uh, not just what works, but asking and digging in, like how do we make this work for our specific business. Um, so hopefully we'll bring you some stories from the trenches, uh, you know, what we're actually doing in our own business and with our clients, what we've been doing with our acquisitions and all that sort of stuff.
Um, and if you've been listening to the show, you'll have heard me recently talk about e-commerce cohorts. We [00:12:00] used to have an e-commerce cohort where people paid to be a member, and that was great and I loved it. And you listen to the show, we're gonna release some of the content from cohorts. From the paid cohorts onto the e-commerce podcast, we're gonna make those available for free.
Because cohort, we have changed it. We're no longer charging for the cohort memberships. Uh, the cohort now is, uh, free. So free membership groups, uh, where you can work alongside other entrepreneurs to actually implement what you are learning to learn from your peers, your e-commerce peers, and share stories and share scars because there's a truth, right?
That we can, we can just spend all our time learning, can't we? You can listen to a thousand podcasts. I know this 'cause I'm an avid podcast, podcast listener. I love listening to podcasts, but listening to a thousand podcasts is not the same as working through 10 ideas with my peers who get it. 'cause guess which one actually moves the needle.
Which [00:13:00] one moves your business forward? Um, I, you know, one cohort member recently just shared with me that they, um. They went from working two days a week on their business, their econ business, to three days a week. Not because of some magical tactic, but because, you know, working with others gave them the confidence and the clarity to take that leap.
Now sure, it's not the, well, I joined cohort and I went from zero to a million in 30 days, but you know what I'm, I'm grateful about that because that story I think applies to. Wow, what 0.0, 0, 0 0 1% of our listeners maybe. But you know what? Getting the opportunity to reduce your part-time job to work more on your e-commerce business, I think that applies to thousands more.
I genuinely do. So we're gonna be talking about stuff that actually matters to all of us. Now let me be completely transparent about why I'm doing this because, uh, one, I [00:14:00] just wanna be transparent and two. I just wanna be transparent, right? It's always a good thing, isn't it? Um, why am I doing this? Well, the podcast helps me grow my business.
I mean, it's an obvious statement to make, but it genuinely does. When we first started the podcast back in 2019, it started as a passion project. I just wanted to do it just to see where it went really and see what happened. I had no strategy. Um, it's not like now where we help other people set up podcasts 'cause of all the stuff that we've learned.
Um. I had a strategy. I had no strategy. We just had a microphone. That was about it really. But over the years, over the 20 years, we've built, you know, multiple seven figure operations and a portion of that success. Has come from relationships I've established through podcasting right now. When I give value freely, I meet some amazing people.
Some of those people then become clients, [00:15:00] and some of those also become partners. We've even acquired businesses through connections made here. Just recently, we took an equity stake and partnered with seven Yays. Um, which is a, you know, it's a, it's a work in progress. That company, um, and that relationship started through content and conversations, which is just brilliant.
Right? Love it. Absolutely love it. It's a great business. Um, and I'm really excited about the future of it, but the podcast grows my business. Just again, full transparency. My coaching rate, what I charge for coaching is $4,000 a day. Right. And there are frameworks that we share, that we've shared with.
Companies all over the world were the large pharmaceutical companies to small e-com companies, right? People have paid serious money for them, but we're gonna put them all out here for free on the podcast coming up, um, over the coming months. Why? Well, we've just, we've shifted our business model [00:16:00] a little bit, um, and it's based on the premise.
You know, you sow, you reap. The more people I help grow, the more our ecosystem seems to thrive. It's one of the things that I've noticed,
the more successful e-commerce businesses there are out there, well, the reality is the more potential partners we have. So it's not totally selfless, I'm gonna be honest with you.
Um, but it is a journey that I'm looking forward to. I genuinely looking forward to, you know, e-commerce is constantly moving. The playing field is, is evolving all the time. The rules, the boundaries. I mean, you've gotta stay up to date or you are quickly irrelevant, doing the podcast, interviewing guests, prepping content, doing the research.
It means I have to stay sharp, right? I can't, I've gotta do that. Um, so like learning that fact that only 2% of, uh, well, two to 8% of folks finish and put into practice what they learn on courses that they have paid for. I find that really interesting, right? When I [00:17:00] do the research and it helps me, you know, when figuring out ways to put content together that actually helps people.
So, all the courses that we've done historically, if they still make sense today. We're talking at the moment about, do we just put them all online and make them free for everyone to access? I don't know. We'll see. Right? So truthfully, the more I learn from implementing alongside you, the better I can serve our equity partners, our coaching clients.
The podcast, what we're doing, it's not a charity, total transparency, but what we're building is that idea of a rising tide that lifts all boats. You sow, you reap. It's the Alex Hormoz approach. Just put content out there that is valuable and you'll be amazed what comes back. Right. So that's, that's it.
That's why we're doing it. The total transparency, and here's my challenge to you, right. Uh, as I wrap up
today's episode, stop taking notes and start taking action. Simple principle, right?
[00:18:00] Pick one thing from each episode, so when you listen, just take one thing. If you're not implementing right, take one thing and then do it, and then tell me what happened.
Reach out to me on LinkedIn @mattedmundson and let me know. The other thing you can do. Which I'd totally appreciate actually, is send me in your questions. So in these solo episodes, I'd really love to do a deep dive on some of the things that you've got top of mind, some of the questions, some of the challenges that you are facing, um, in e-commerce.
Running a business, all that sort of stuff, whatever they are, fire 'em across 'cause well, you know, we'd love to get in there and, and deliver some content that creates value for us. Over the coming weeks you'll see this evolution sort of roll out. We've got new solo episodes tackling stuff like preparing for the summer sales slump, which you know, at the time.
As I, as we started to do this, that seemed like a good idea. We're just a bit delayed in getting these episodes [00:19:00] out, so that that's probably gonna come out maybe a little bit too late, but it. The idea is it will help you prepare and learn for next year. We're gonna be talking about Black Friday. We've got some content from Cohort, which I mentioned, which we are gonna be releasing for free.
Um, especially the stuff around Black Friday that's gonna be coming up as well. Um, because if you're listening to this, you, you should definitely be thinking about Black Friday. If I go, you know, if this comes out when I think it's coming out, you should definitely be thinking about it. We are gonna dig into the mindset shifts that separate six figure survivors from seven figure thrivers.
Love, love, love that phrase. Um. So, yeah, we're gonna be getting to all of that. You know, some of the still the stuff that we find out. Now, let me just bring you up to speed on the e-commerce cohort. If you've been a regular to the show, you'll have heard me mention about this over the last few weeks.
E-commerce cohort has had wait lists in the US and in the UK for the new cohorts that are starting. They are gonna launch, uh, after the summer, um, [00:20:00] probably around September, October time. So if you haven't done so already, make sure you're signed up for these, these aren't the courses. Um, and it may be that all the courses we have done and deliver free, we'll put in, in effect into the cohort.
There's some conversations around that. But cohort is free to join. They aren't courses that, let's just call them implementation groups, right? Think of them. As a sort of a board of your peers who are also your advisors. You know, they're all in the trenches with you and they are completely free. So do check that out.
Um, you can go to the website eCommerce podcast.net, um, and check that out, uh, and learn more about it. Just click the cohort button. Uh, honestly, it'd be great to see you in there. Uh, the other thing that's happening again, you'll have heard me talk about this on the show. Starting in September, our new newsletter, um, is gonna be launching as a complete overhaul, not just the, here's what this week's episode is, you know, with a few lines, but we want to make sure that there's some real additional value in [00:21:00] there.
The stuff, you know, that I can't fit into the 20 minutes basically. So, um, again, with these solo episodes, we're gonna be doing. Worksheets, checklists, freebies, those kind of things that sit alongside it that you can get access to. Um, all of that sort of stuff will also be in the newsletter. So yeah, lot of change coming up.
Let's change, let's say there's pivots. Um, no, let's not say pivots 'cause I hate that word. Let's say improvements. Uh, let's use that word, um, because I just, I, I just love this show and we really want to help deliver more and more value. So, uh, you know, we this real passion for focusing, you know, on that gap between learning and doing, because after 20 years in e-commerce, after building and selling multiple businesses, and even after my $38 million lesson.
I know the difference between the businesses that thrive and those that merely survive is not knowledge, not in this day and age. It's [00:22:00] not even talent. I think a lot
of it is the ability to take imperfect action consistently. Everyone out there is waiting for the perfect strategy.
You know, the revolutionary tactic, the course that changes everything, but the real secret.
I think it's doing the basics brilliantly. Learning from what actually happens, not what you think should happen, and having people around you who get it right. And that's what these solo episodes are all about. That's what cohort is all about, and that's what this entire evolution is all about, because learning is not the same.
As implementation. I'll say that again.
It's one of my favorite phrases. Learning is not the same as implementation, and I reckon
it's probably time we all stop pretending otherwise. Look, if you are serious about [00:23:00] actually implementing, instead of just learning, join the seriously join the cohort, the links in the description, uh, in the show notes.
Or like I say, head over to eCommerce podcast.net. Uh, send me your questions, you know, the messy specific actual problems that you are facing. 'cause maybe just maybe, uh, we'll do one of these shows on that particular problem and let's work through them. Let's see what happens. And remember. That folder of great ideas on your desktop, open it.
I dare you. Open it, pick one thing, implement it this week, and then drop me a note telling me about what happened. After all, your implementation story is worth more than another expert's theory.